Review: The Daughter's Tale

Title: The Daughter's Tale

Author: Armando Lucas Correa

Publisher: 1st June 2019 by Simon & Schuster (Australia)

Pages: 320 pages

How I Read It: ARC book

Genre: historical fiction

My Rating: 3.5 cups

Synopsis:

Based on the true story of the Nazi massacre of a French village in 1944, an unforgettable tale of love and redemption from the bestselling author of The German Girl. 

New York City, 2015: Elise Duval, eighty years old, receives a phone call from a woman recently arrived from Cuba bearing messages from a time and country that she's long forgotten. A French Catholic who arrived in New York after World War II, Elise and her world are forever changed when the woman arrives with letters written to Elise from her mother in German during the war, unravelling more than seven decades of secrets. 

Berlin, 1939: Bookstore owner and recent widow Amanda Sternberg is fleeing Nazi Germany with her two young daughters, heading towards unoccupied France. She arrives in Haute-Vienne with only one of her girls. Their freedom is short-lived and soon they are taken to a labour camp. 

Inspired by one of the most shocking atrocities perpetrated by the Nazis during World War II, the 1944 massacre of all the inhabitants of the village of Oradour-Sur-Glane in the south of France, The Daughter's Tale is a beautifully crafted family saga of love, survival and hope against all odds.

My Thoughts

“Everybody has their opinion. Everybody thinks they’re right, but where does that get them? Nowhere. Nobody does anything,”

Armando Correa’s, “The German Girl” was fabulous and I could not wait to try his latest tale. Don’t go in expecting strong links to his previous book as the link is tenuous. What we do have is another heart breaking story of survival against the power of Nazi Germany. 

Yes, this is another war time story, however ultimately, it is more of  a book about mothers and their daughters with the often heart wrenching decisions they had to make in an effort to protect their children. Inspired by actual events, Correa presents a fictional family, highlighting the courage people had to have when caught up in events not of their making. His writing is engaging as you are taken on a journey with first the mother and then later her daughter and their attempts to survive. You will be introduced to many strong supporting secondary characters who assist both Amanda and Lina - but ultimately this really is the story of young Lina as we also encounter her in present day New York.

Sadly however, this was not as complete a tale as ‘The German Girl’. In the blurb a clear emphasis is placed on the horrific events of the massacre but very little of the story is dedicated to that. There are many characters with much going on that it does, at times, get somewhat  confusing and some character stories are left unresolved. This then led to a seemingly abrupt ending that appeared a little rushed. The story of modern day Elise seemed superfluous to me as it contributed little to the overall tale and required more fleshing out for it to be meaningful. This would have been beneficial, particularly concerning characters such as the other sister, Viera, and her story in Cuba - she seemed quite forgotten once she boarded the boat. 

‘She knew well that no matter how the author fashions his characters, no matter which words he chooses, it is always the reader who holds the power of interpretation.’

A Daughter’s Tale is, overall, a moving WWII novel with a strong focus on the themes of family, hope, faith and above all, identity in a search for who you really are.

“You know something, Adele? I’ve lived so many lives, I don’t know which of them is coming to an end now.”

This review is based on a complimentary copy from the publisher and provided through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The quoted material may have changed in the final release.

Review: The German Girl

Title: The German Girl

Author: Armando Lucas Correa

Publisher: 1 December 2016 by Simon and Schuster (Australia)

Pages: 368 pages

How I Read It: ARC book

Genre: historical fiction, world war II

My Rating: 5 cups

Synopsis:

Before everything changed, Hannah Rosenthal lived a charmed life. But now the streets of Berlin are draped in swastikas and Hannah is no longer welcome in the places she once considered home.

A glimmer of hope appears in the shape of the St Louis, a transatlantic liner that promises Jews safe passage to Cuba. The Rosenthals sell everything to fund visas and tickets. At first the liner feels like luxury, but as they travel the circumstances of war change, and it soon becomes their prison.

Seven decades later in New York, on her twelfth birthday Anna Rosen receives a package from Hannah, the great-aunt she never met but who raised her deceased father. Anna and her mother immediately travel to Cuba to meet this elderly relative, and for the first time Hannah tells them the untold story of her voyage on the St Louis.

My Thoughts

‘We would belong forever to the exiles, to the people nobody wanted, the ones who had been forced from their homes since the dawn of time.’

I consider myself a fairly well-read person, but this, I knew nothing about. This is the story of the St. Louis, a ship that promised safe passage from Germany to Cuba, in May 1939. The ship’s 937 passengers were almost all Jews fleeing the Third Reich and seeking asylum. This is truly an unforgettable debut novel and congratulations to Correa for bringing this little known event to the public spotlight. For you see, only 28 were allowed to disembark in Cuba, and the remaining were forced to sail back as few countries would accept them. Powerful stuff, and as expressed in the book:

‘By shedding light onto the tragedies of our past, Correa invites us to reflect on the troubles that are still impacting refugees all over the world today.’

Correa bases a fictional story around the 1939 Saint Louis journey and there is just much to love about this book. I loved the story of Hannah and Leo so much, their relationship is memorably heartbreaking. Not to mention the heroic captain, Gustav Schroder, that will have you running to Google more on the short and long term fallout of the whole disaster.  I was also fascinated by the parallels drawn between Nazi Germany and Communist Cuba - something I had never considered. Then there are the rich and evocative descriptive scenes set in  Berlin, the St Louis and Cuba which  are vivid and real.

‘We, the ridiculously gullible ones, had believed the Ogres when they authorized us to leave after handing over our businesses, our homes, our fortunes. How on earth could we have been so stupid as to trust them?’

The story alternates between that of Hannah and Anna, their joys and heartbreaks, their friendships and fears. Given the material for this story, you might be thinking it is depressing - and no doubt there is plenty of tragedy that is confronting; however, it will move you in a more reflective way. It is powerful and emotional, with moments of joy that brought a lump to my throat. Let’s be frank, even after all these years the author bravely presents a fresh angle on a sensitive topic. But gosh! It is done well. I would go as far as to say this is a stunning debut novel that moved me to my core.

“Millions of men with no work. Millions of children with no future. Save the German people!” I am German, too. Who was going to save me?”

I highly recommend this book to historical fiction fans. Take Hannah’s hand and run along the streets of Berlin, sail to Cuba with her and hold her hand even tighter as she finally confronts her memories and promises made. ‘The German Girl’ will pull at your heartstrings and rates as one of my best reads for 2016.

“Every day I wonder why I’m still alive!” she whispers, suddenly bursting into tears.

This review is based on a complimentary copy from the publisher and provided through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The quoted material may have changed in the final release